Back to Bookshelf Back

Emotionally Healthy Spirituality

It's Impossible to Be Spiritually Mature, While Remaining Emotionally Immature

Scazzero shows that you can't grow up in Christ while you stay emotionally immature.

Listen to the Summary

0:00 0:00

Chapter 1 — The Problem of Emotionally Unhealthy Spirituality

Following Jesus without emotional health can be deadly. It can hurt you, your relationship with God, and the people around you. The author, Pete Scazzero, learned this the hard way. He was the pastor of New Life Fellowship Church in Queens, New York. And he tells a story he wishes he could forget.

One hot Sunday in July, a visiting couple named John and Susan drove a long way to attend the church’s three services. Between services, they asked to spend some time with Pete and his wife, Geri. Pete was exhausted. But the couple’s pastor was a friend of his, and Pete worried what they would say about him if he sent them home. So he lied. “Sure, I would love to have you for a late-afternoon lunch. I’m sure Geri would too!”

At the kitchen table, John talked, and talked, and talked. Susan said nothing. Pete pretended to listen. Inside, he was angry, and then he felt guilty for being angry. After a long time, during a rare pause, Geri spoke up. “I haven’t heard from Faith in a while.” Faith was their three-year-old daughter. John kept right on talking.

Finally, Geri went to look. No Faith in the basement. No Faith in the bedrooms. She ran back into the kitchen. “Pete! Oh my God, I can’t find her. She’s not here!” They ran to the small pool in the backyard. There stood Faith, in the middle of it, on her tiptoes, with the water up to her chin. If she had slipped, they would have been burying their daughter.

Looking back, Pete saw the truth. “John wasn’t the problem; I was.” On the outside, he had looked kind and patient. On the inside, he was nothing like that. He wanted so badly to look like a good Christian that he shut out what was really going on inside him. Pretending was safer than honesty and vulnerability. And because of that, Faith almost died. Even then, nothing changed inside him. That would take five more years and a lot more pain.

How could a pastor live like this? Pete had become a Christian at nineteen, gone to seminary, and started a church. But for seventeen years, almost no one talked about the emotional side of life. So that part of him stayed untouched.

Church life can even become a hiding place. When people meet God in worship, prayer, and Bible study, they assume they are doing fine. They think this even when their relationships are broken and their inner life is a mess. Pete compares a person to an iceberg. Only about 10 percent of an iceberg shows above the water. That is the part people see: we go to church, act nicer, and clean up bad habits. But most of who we are sits below the surface. And a large part of it stays untouched by Jesus.

Three things finally forced Pete to look below the surface. First, he had no joy, even though Jesus promised, “My yoke is easy and my burden is light.” Second, he was angry and depressed. His church had an afternoon service in Spanish. When Pete’s associate in that Spanish service left to start a church of his own, he took two hundred of its two hundred and fifty members with him. Pete found himself hating the man. He preached love and forgiveness on Sundays and cursed alone in his car on Mondays.

The third thing was Geri. She was lonely and tired of raising their four daughters like a single mom. One evening, she walked into their bedroom and calmly told him, “Pete, I’d be happier single than married to you.” Then she added, “Oh, yes, by the way, the church you pastor? I quit. Your leadership isn’t worth following.” Pete now calls it probably the most loving thing Geri has done in their whole marriage. She had seen something vital. It is not possible to be spiritually mature while remaining emotionally immature.

Without emotional growth, people get stuck. As one man in Pete’s church put it, “I was a Christian for twenty-two years. But instead of being a twenty-two-year-old Christian, I was a one-year-old Christian twenty-two times!”

Pete names ten warning signs of this stuck kind of faith. The first is using God to run from God, staying busy with church activity to avoid what God wants to change. The second is ignoring anger, sadness, and fear. The third is dying to the wrong things. You are called to die to your sin, not to God’s good gifts, like friendship, music, laughter, and nature. The fourth is denying that your past shapes your present. The fifth is splitting life into sacred and secular. Think of the man who sings about God’s love at church and then wishes another driver dead on the way home.

The sixth sign is doing for God instead of being with God. The seventh is sweeping conflict under the rug. The eighth is hiding weakness and failure. The ninth is living without limits. And the tenth is judging other people’s spiritual journeys.

So what is the way out? Pete joins emotional health with what he calls contemplative spirituality, which simply means a slower, quieter life of being with God. The rest of the book walks through seven pathways. Know yourself. Look back at the family you came from. Go through a hard season Pete calls the Wall. Grieve your losses. Slow down with daily prayer and a weekly Sabbath. Grow up emotionally, so you can love people well. And make a simple plan to keep it all going. The first pathway is knowing yourself so that you may know God.

Chapter 2 — Know Yourself That You May Know God

Christians have long known that knowing God and knowing yourself go together. Around AD 400, Augustine prayed, “Grant, Lord, that I may know myself that I may know thee.” Yet most people go to their graves without knowing who they are. They live someone else’s life, or at least someone else’s expectations for them.

Pete learned this through another hard moment with Geri. A year and a half after she quit his church, she had come back, and their marriage was doing better. Then one day she told him she was going to spend July at her mother’s house at the New Jersey shore. For ten years, she had given in to his objections. Now she was done.

Pete raised his voice. “You can’t leave me alone all month by myself here in New York. It will wreck our marriage.” That wasn’t true, and he knew it. Deep down, he wanted Geri to be the mother he never had, and he worried what people would think. He pouted. He sulked. She went anyway. He hated it. She loved it. But over time, God used those weeks alone to help Pete grow into his own person, apart from Geri. And breaking free started with learning to feel.

Pete had been taught that feelings can’t be trusted. But the Bible shows a God who feels. God’s heart is “deeply troubled.” Jesus is “full of joy.” And in the garden, Jesus says, “My soul is overwhelmed with sorrow to the point of death.” You are made in God’s image. God thinks. You think. God wills. You will. God feels. You feel.

When you deny your feelings year after year, you turn into an empty shell with a smiley face painted on it. Pete had stuffed his emotions for thirty-six years. When he finally let himself feel them, he found that God could handle them. Pete came alive like never before.

Knowing yourself also means knowing where your worth comes from. Before Jesus did a single miracle, his Father said, “This is my Son, whom I love; with him I am well pleased.” Then, in the wilderness, the devil tempted Jesus with three lies. They are the same lies you face. “I am what I do.” “I am what I have.” “I am what others think.” Each one says that God’s love will never be enough.

Sheila Walsh once cohosted the TV show The 700 Club. She measured herself by what other people thought of her, and it was slowly killing her. “One morning I was sitting on national television with my nice suit and inflatable hairdo and that night I was in the locked ward of a psychiatric hospital.” The psychiatrist asked her, “Who are you?” Each time she named one of her jobs, he said, “That’s not what I meant.” Finally, she admitted, “I don’t have a clue.” He replied, “Now that’s right and that’s why you’re here.”

Jesus knew he was loved, so he could stay true to himself, even when it disappointed his family, his friends, and the crowds. He held on to who he was under pressure, and he still stayed close to people.

Pete offers four steps to help your true self grow. First, take time for silence and solitude. Pete began by feeling his emotions before God each day and writing them in a journal. He also cut his workweek from about seventy hours to forty-five. Second, find trusted companions, because it’s easy to fool yourself.

Third, step out of your comfort zone. Running a large church like a CEO was crushing Pete. What he loved was preaching, writing, time with God, and loving people. So, slowly, he changed how he served, and the church blossomed. As Rabbi Zusya said in an old Jewish story, “In the coming world, they will not ask me: ‘Why were you not Moses?’ They will ask me, ‘Why were you not Zusya?’”

Fourth, pray for courage. When you change, the people closest to you often push back. In effect, they say, “Change back and we will accept you again.” Keep going anyway. Your life may shake as you grow, but God is with you. And as you get to know yourself, one of the first places to look is where you came from.

Chapter 3 — Going Back in Order to Go Forward

God chose to place you in a particular family, in a particular place, at a particular moment in history. That choice gave you gifts. It also handed you some emotional baggage. True spirituality frees you to live joyfully in the present. But to get there, you have to go back in order to go forward.

One day, a man from Pete’s church named Frank met him at a diner, visibly shaken. “Maria told me last night that she wasn’t sure she loved me anymore,” he said. His wife was tired of him being distant. Both of them had grown up in Christian homes. They had heard thousands of sermons, served on the worship team, and gone on marriage retreats. Yet they were miserable.

As they kept meeting, Frank opened up about his family. His grandfather had been an abusive alcoholic. His father became a Christian but struggled his whole life with a sexual addiction. Maria’s father was an alcoholic who later came to faith, but he stayed emotionally absent. Without knowing it, Frank and Maria were living out patterns that went back generations.

The Bible says family sins are passed down “to the third and fourth generation.” You can see it in Genesis. Abraham lied about his wife. His son Isaac had a marriage full of lies. Isaac’s son Jacob had a name that means “deceiver.” Then ten of Jacob’s sons faked their brother Joseph’s death and kept the secret for years. More is caught than taught.

Every family hands down its own rules, and most of them are never spoken out loud. “Avoid conflict at all costs.” “Sadness is a sign of weakness.” One of the deadliest is “You must achieve to be loved.” Many people know what it’s like to be approved for what they do. Few know what it’s like to be loved just for who they are. These rules don’t vanish when you become a Christian. The Israelites left Egypt, but a great deal of Egypt stayed in them.

Pete’s own Italian-American family had its rules too. His mother grew up with an abusive father. She battled depression, and Pete’s father was emotionally unavailable. So, as a boy, Pete’s job was to “make Mama happy.” As a Christian, he kept it up. He took care of everyone. He worked hard to prove himself. He gave in to end conflict, just like his father. And he never let himself feel. Pete says he “lost a leg” in his childhood. But because he went back and faced it, he can walk. He may walk with a limp, but he is no longer crippled.

Here is the great news. Your family of origin does not determine your future. God does. In Christ, you are adopted into a new family with a new Father. Jesus once looked at the people seated around him and said, “Here are my mother and my brothers! Whoever does God’s will is my brother and sister and mother.” You honor your parents, but you obey God. And when you face the truth about your family, you get to choose. “This is what I want to keep. This is what I do not want to bring with me to the next generation.”

Joseph shows the way. His brothers sold him as a slave into Egypt, and later he sat forgotten in prison for years. Then, overnight, he became the second most powerful man in Egypt. He gave his first son a name that means “forget,” because God had helped him forget his troubles. Years later, when he saw his brothers again, he wept so loudly that the Egyptians heard him. He didn’t pretend the pain away, but he saw God’s hand in it. “It was not you who sent me here, but God,” he told them. And instead of destroying his brothers, he blessed them. Going back like this is hard. For most people, it leads straight to a Wall.

Chapter 4 — Journey through the Wall

Sooner or later, every follower of Jesus hits what Pete calls the Wall. Christians long ago called it “the dark night of the soul.” It is a season when your faith seems to stop working. Many people get stuck there, or quit. But growing into maturity in Christ requires going through the Wall.

It is God who brings you to the Wall, usually through a crisis. It might be a divorce, a job loss, a death, cancer, a betrayal, a wayward child, or a dream that dies. Suddenly your faith doesn’t seem to “work.” You don’t know where God is or what he is doing.

Pete’s Wall was the hard season from the first chapter. It began when his Spanish-speaking congregation split. Then came a long depression, the crisis in his marriage, and a hard look at his family. For the first time, Pete could not feel God. The Bible turned to dust. When he told a former church member he had hit rock bottom, she laughed. “You have no idea how much further you have to go!” She was right. It lasted more than two more years. At one point, Pete asked God, “Is there anything else you want to rip out of me, you sadist?”

Pete kept praying and serving, though everything in him wanted to quit. Then, slowly, he came out the other side. “Something is different,” he told himself. “Totally different. I cannot explain it, but I feel freer than ever from people’s opinions, more clear about who I am, more certain of God and his love than ever!”

What was God doing? Centuries ago, a Christian writer named John of the Cross explained it. In the dark night, your good feelings about God disappear, and the old prayer habits stop working. But God is freeing you from the things you cling to, even your good feelings about him. Those feelings are not God. They are only messengers from God.

Don’t mistake everyday trials for the Wall. Traffic jams and barking dogs in the middle of the night are trials. Walls are much bigger. Walls are David running from a jealous king for thirteen years. They are Abraham waiting twenty-five years for a son. They are Job losing his ten children in one day.

People who make it through the Wall come out changed. Pete names four signs. First, they are broken, and they stop judging others. A good test is how easily you get offended. A broken person is so secure in God’s love that when someone criticizes her, she thinks to herself, “It is far worse than you think!”

Second, they love mystery. As Augustine wrote, “If you understand, it is not God you understand.” Most of the time, you have no idea what God is doing. An old Chinese story makes the point. When a man’s son lost his horse, the father asked, “What makes you so sure this is not a blessing?” Months later, the horse came back with a fine stallion. Then the son fell off the stallion and broke his hip. A year later, war came, and nine of every ten men on the border died. The son lived only because he was lame.

Third, they can wait for God. Pete says his greatest sins and mistakes all go back to one thing: a failure to wait on the Lord.

Fourth, they hold things more loosely. The real question is not “Am I happy?” but “Am I free?” Pete borrows five hard truths from the writer Richard Rohr, and he says the Wall teaches them all: “Life is hard. You are not that important. Your life is not about you. You are not in control. You are going to die.” You still enjoy God’s good gifts. You just hold them loosely, so you can love God more. And part of letting go is learning to grieve what you have lost.

Chapter 5 — Enlarge Your Soul through Grief and Loss

There is no greater disaster in the spiritual life than to be immersed in unreality. Loss is where real change happens, if you have the courage to face it. And behind every loss is a limit. God puts limits around even the most gifted people to keep them grounded and humble. In fact, the word humility comes from the Latin humus, meaning “of the earth.”

Most people lose things slowly, over a lifetime: their youth, their dreams, their health, their jobs, and sometimes their wrong ideas about God. Job lost everything in a single afternoon, including his ten children. Amazingly, he worshiped. Then painful sores covered his body, and his wife told him, “Curse God and die.” What makes it so hard is that Job was innocent. His suffering had nothing to do with his sin.

Most people run from pain. They stay busy, overwork, overeat, or drink. Many Christians even feel guilty for being sad. A young Jewish student named Hilda went to a Christian classmate’s funeral. The family held it as a celebration, with no mourning. The next day, Hilda exploded at a Christian she knew from work. “Don’t you people cry or mourn? I don’t get it. Are you people human beings at all?!” Yet Jesus himself wept.

Gerald Sittser found a better way. He lost his mother, his wife, and his young daughter in one car accident. He learned that the quickest way to reach the sun is not to run west chasing it, but to head east, into the darkness, until you reach the sunrise.

Job shows how to grieve well, in five phases. First, pay attention. When someone asks how you are after a loss, don’t just say, “Couldn’t be better!” Job didn’t. He cursed the day he was born and told God exactly how he felt, for thirty-five chapters. Two-thirds of the psalms are laments, prayers of complaint to God. When you stuff your anger and sadness instead, they leak out. They come out in sarcasm, a nasty tone of voice, or the silent treatment.

Second, wait in the confusing in-between. Job’s three friends insisted he was suffering because of his sin. They tried to fix Job and defend God, and they only tortured a man who was already in great pain. Have you ever felt worse after talking with people who were trying to make you feel better?

Third, accept the gift of limits. Your body, your talents, your money, and your time all have limits. Only Jesus has every gift. When the crowds left John the Baptist to follow Jesus, John’s followers complained. But John said, “A person can receive only what is given them from heaven.” Jesus must increase, he said, and I must decrease.

Fourth, climb the ladder of humility. When God finally spoke, Job had a chance to get back at his friends. Instead, he prayed for them. Long ago, Saint Benedict described humility as a ladder you climb one step at a time. At the top, you are transformed into the love of God. You stop putting others down. You accept your limits and theirs. Everything is a gift.

Fifth, let the old give birth to the new. Job’s old life was gone for good. But God gave him twice as much as before, and ten children again. Jesus said that unless a kernel of wheat falls to the ground and dies, it stays a single seed. But if it dies, it produces many seeds. Resurrection only comes out of death, real death. Your losses are real. And so is your God, the living God.

When you grieve God’s way, your prayers change too. You move from “Give me, give me, and give me” to a close, loving union with God. Two ancient practices help you stay there, day by day and week by week.

Chapter 6 — Discover the Rhythms of the Daily Office and Sabbath

Farmers in the Midwest used to get ready for blizzards by tying a rope from the back door of the house to the barn. When a storm hit full force, a farmer couldn’t see his own hand. If he lost his grip on the rope, he might never find his way home. Some froze to death within feet of their own front door.

Many people are lost in a blizzard of their own. It begins when you say yes to too many things. You multitask, you hurry, and you fall into bed exhausted. When you aren’t busy, you feel guilty. God offers you a rope in two ancient practices: the Daily Office and the Sabbath. They aren’t one more thing for your to-do list. They reset your whole life toward God.

Start with the Daily Office. For years, Pete would spend time with God in the morning and lose track of him within hours. By dinner, his family was wondering, “What happened to Dad’s Christianity?” Then Pete spent a week with Trappist monks who stopped to pray together seven times a day. He was sure this rhythm of stopping was a key to staying aware of God all day long. That is the Daily Office: stopping at set times each day to be with God.

You don’t have to become a monk. Pete stops for four Offices a day. Geri aims for three, and she skips one without any guilt. An Office can last two minutes or forty-five. Each one has four parts. First, stop what you’re doing, and trust God to run his world without you. Second, center yourself. Sit still and breathe slowly. Third, be silent. When God came to the prophet Elijah, God was not in the wind, the earthquake, or the fire. He came in what the Hebrew literally calls “a sound of sheer silence.” Fourth, read Scripture, especially the psalms.

Keep it simple. If it helps, do it. If it doesn’t, don’t. And remember, nothing you do will make God love you any more than he does right now.

The second rope is the Sabbath. The word comes from a Hebrew word meaning “to cease, to stop working.” It is a twenty-four-hour break from work, once a week. God’s people had been slaves in Egypt for over four hundred years, and they never had a day off. When God set them free, he gave them a rhythm of work and rest. It is often said that for thirty-five hundred years, the Sabbath has kept the Jews more than the Jews have kept the Sabbath.

A true Sabbath has four parts. First, stop. You’ll never finish everything, and the world keeps working fine without you. A wagon train of Christians heading to Oregon once split in two as winter came on. One group kept stopping for the Sabbath. The other pressed on seven days a week. The Sabbath group got there first, because their people and horses were rested.

Second, rest. Do whatever delights and refreshes you, and save the bills and laundry for another day. Third, delight. Slow down and enjoy God’s gifts. Pete remembers the first time he slowly enjoyed warm water running over his hands in a McDonald’s restroom on a Sabbath. He tasted the Sabbath gift of simply washing his hands. Fourth, contemplate. Worship, Scripture, and silence make each Sabbath a small taste of the feast to come in heaven.

Think of the Sabbath as a heavy snow day every week. You’re free to play, nap, or read a good book. God gives you fifty-two snow days a year. Pete has also taken a few longer breaks of three or four months, called sabbaticals. They changed him so much that Geri jokes, “I have been married to four different men the last thirty-two years, all of them named Pete Scazzero.”

The monk and writer Thomas Merton called overwork and the rush of modern life a form of violence. And when you do violence to yourself, you can’t love others well. Loving others well is the next pathway.

Chapter 7 — Grow into an Emotionally Mature Adult

In Dostoevsky’s novel The Brothers Karamazov, a wealthy woman dreams of a life serving the poor. Then she pictures them complaining that the soup isn’t hot enough or the bread isn’t fresh. She can’t bear such ingratitude, and her dream vanishes. A wise old monk tells her, “Love in practice is a harsh and dreadful thing compared to love in dreams.” Loving well is the goal of the Christian life. To do it, you have to grow up emotionally.

Jessica shows why. She had been a Christian for fifteen years and loved spending time with God. Her company’s vice president asked her to pick the weeks she’d like to travel to meet clients. She sent him her dates and heard nothing back. When she called, his assistant said the schedule was full. “I guess this means he doesn’t need you right now.” For two weeks, Jessica asked God to forgive her anger and lost sleep. Then she quietly pulled away from the vice president and the other managers. Eventually, she left the company. She loved Jesus. But she didn’t know how to relate to people in an emotionally mature way.

Jesus knew inspiration wasn’t enough. So he lived with twelve disciples for three years and had them practice what he taught. People need skills too. Many people are forty-five years old but still emotional infants, children, or teenagers. Emotional infants expect others to take care of them. Emotional children fall apart when they don’t get their way. Emotional teenagers get defensive and keep score. Emotional adults ask clearly and honestly for what they need. They respect others without trying to change them.

The root problem is that everyone sees life from the center of their own universe. At their wedding, Pete and Geri lit a unity candle and announced, “We are one.” But which one? For the first nine years of marriage, Pete’s unspoken answer was, “Yes, Geri and I are one, and I am the one!”

The Jewish thinker Martin Buber described two kinds of relationships. In an “I-It” relationship, you treat a person like an object, the way you would use a toothbrush or a car. In an “I-Thou” relationship, you see the other person as made in God’s image, separate from you and worthy of respect. Thou is simply an old word for you. When you love someone this way, God fills the space between you. The separate space between you becomes sacred space.

This changes how you handle conflict. Many Christians think “Blessed are the peacemakers” means keeping everyone happy. Pete calls that false peacemaking. Picture Bob at dinner with a big group. Money is tight, so he orders only a salad and an appetizer. Everyone else orders steak, wine, and dessert. Then someone suggests splitting the bill evenly. Bob is dying inside, but he says nothing. Jesus disrupted false peace everywhere he went, because you can’t build his kingdom on lies and pretense. True peacemakers love God, others, and themselves enough to disrupt false peace.

That takes skills. Pete teaches several, and here are four. The first is speaking and listening. The speaker talks briefly about their own thoughts and feelings. The listener puts their own agenda on hold, repeats back what they heard, and asks, “Is there more?” The second is to stop mind reading. Jessica assumed she knew why her boss dropped her, but she never checked. Instead, you can say, “I think you think,” fill in the blank, and ask, “Is this correct?”

The third skill is to clarify expectations. An expectation is only fair when both people know about it and agree to it. Otherwise, it’s just a hope. The fourth is to notice your emotional allergies. An emotional allergy is a strong reaction to something in the present that reminds you of your past. For years, when Geri wanted a weekend away with her girlfriends, Pete reacted badly. It reminded him of how his parents had not been there for him. In moments like that, you treat the person in front of you like an It.

None of this comes naturally. But look at the twelve men Jesus chose. Peter had a big problem with his mouth. James and John were hotheads known as the “sons of thunder.” Matthew was the most hated man in his town. They were neither spiritually nor emotionally mature. But most of them had one great quality: they were willing. That is all God asks of you. To keep growing, though, you need a plan.

Chapter 8 — Go the Next Step to Develop a Rule of Life

The last pathway pulls everything together in a plan Pete calls a Rule of Life. Don’t let the word rule scare you. It comes from the Greek word for “trellis.” A trellis helps a grapevine get off the ground and grow upward, so it bears more fruit. A Rule of Life does the same for you. It is a simple, planned way to keep God at the center of everything you do. And it starts with a desire to be with God and to love him.

Everyone already has a rule, even if they don’t know it. Maybe yours is church on Sundays and ten minutes of prayer before bed. But that isn’t enough to keep you afloat in today’s world. Daniel knew what he was up against. As a teenager, he was carried off to Babylon and given a new name and a pagan education, all to absorb him into Babylon’s ways. But Daniel had a plan. He refused the king’s food, and he prayed at set times every day. Centuries later, Christian monks wrote down plans like this and called them a Rule of Life. The best known was written by Saint Benedict. Its heart fits in one line: “The love of Christ must come before all else.”

Pete suggests twelve things a Rule can include, in four groups. The first group is prayer: Scripture, silence, the Daily Office, and study. The second is rest: Sabbath, simplicity, and play. Geri sums up part of her life mission this way: “Life can be difficult, so have fun whenever you can to the glory of God.” The third group is work: serving others and caring for your body. A headache or a sleepless night may be God calling you to slow down. The fourth group is relationships: your emotional health, your family, and companions for the journey.

Don’t try to do it all at once. Start with one or two things for a few months. For example, you might pray the Jesus Prayer several times a day at work: “Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, a sinner.” Find a companion to help keep you on track, and don’t be hard on yourself. As Benedict wrote, “Do not be daunted immediately by fear and run away from the road that leads to salvation. It is bound to be narrow at the outset.”

God has a different path for each person. It is a tragedy to live someone else’s life. Pete knows, because he did it for years. He closes with a story from Carlo Carretto, a member of a Christian community called the Little Brothers of Jesus. Carretto lived among Muslims in North Africa for ten years. One day, crossing the Sahara by camel, he came upon about fifty men repairing a road in the hot sun. Among them was his friend Paul. Paul had once been an engineer in Paris, working on France’s atomic bomb, until God called him to leave everything and become a Little Brother too.

Paul’s mother couldn’t understand it. “Why can’t he work as an intellectual in the church?” she asked Carretto. “Wouldn’t that be more useful?” Carretto’s answer was love. “It is love that justifies our actions,” he wrote. “If out of love Brother Paul has chosen to die on a desert road, then he is justified.” In the end, he could only say, “Live love, let love invade you. It will never fail to teach you what you must do.”

That is where this whole journey leads. It began at a kitchen table, where a pastor pretended to be patient and kind while his little girl stood on tiptoe in the pool. It led through honest feelings, an honest look at the past, the Wall, grief, and new rhythms of rest. The goal of all of it is to help you love God and the people in front of you well. You don’t have to copy anyone else’s life. You only have to live faithfully the one God has given you. Let love invade you. It will never fail to teach you what you must do.

Practical takeaways

Free · No sign-up required

Questions

What Emotionally Healthy Spirituality is about

Emotionally Healthy Spirituality is Pete Scazzero’s case that closeness to God and emotional health go together. Published in 2006 and updated in 2017, it grew out of Scazzero’s crisis as founding pastor of New Life Fellowship Church in Queens, New York: a church split, depression and a wife who quit the church. Scazzero lists the top 10 symptoms of emotionally unhealthy spirituality, then joins emotional health to contemplative spirituality in seven pathways: know yourself, go back in order to go forward, journey through the Wall, grieve your losses, keep the Daily Office and Sabbath, grow into an emotional adult and follow a Rule of Life.

Who should read it

Christians whose faith looks fine outside while anger, burnout or family patterns run things underneath: the pastor who can’t say no, the believer whose prayers went dry after a loss, the church couple who barely talk at home. Churches can study it in Scazzero’s eight-session Emotionally Healthy Spirituality Course, which adds a workbook with streaming videos and a Day by Day devotional. Readers wary of practices borrowed from monks, like the Daily Office, may be uneasy with parts of it.

The top 10 symptoms of emotionally unhealthy spirituality, in plain words

  • Using God to run from God: staying busy with church activity to avoid what God wants to change.
  • Ignoring anger, sadness and fear.
  • Dying to the wrong things: you are called to die to your sin, not to God’s good gifts, like friendship, music, laughter and nature.
  • Denying that your past shapes your present.
  • Splitting life into sacred and secular, like the man who sings about God’s love at church, then wishes another driver dead on the way home.
  • Doing for God instead of being with God.
  • Sweeping conflict under the rug.
  • Hiding weakness and failure.
  • Living without limits.
  • Judging other people’s spiritual journeys.

Questions people ask

What does Pete Scazzero mean by “impossible to be spiritually mature while remaining emotionally immature”?

That you can pray, study the Bible and serve for years and still not be mature in Christ if you stay emotionally stuck. In Emotionally Healthy Spirituality, Pete Scazzero compares a person to an iceberg: only about 10 percent shows above the water, and most of who we are sits below, much of it untouched by Jesus. Scazzero learned this the hard way, hating a former associate, preaching love on Sundays and cursing alone in the car on Mondays, until Geri Scazzero told her husband, “I quit. Your leadership isn’t worth following.” As one man in their church put it, he had been “a one-year-old Christian twenty-two times.”

What does “know yourself that you may know God” mean in Emotionally Healthy Spirituality?

That you can’t grow close to God while you stay a stranger to yourself. In Emotionally Healthy Spirituality, Pete Scazzero echoes the prayer of Augustine, “Grant, Lord, that I may know myself that I may know thee.” Knowing yourself starts with feelings: God feels, and you are made in God’s image, so you feel too. It also means knowing where your worth comes from. Scazzero notes that the devil tempted Jesus with three lies you face as well: “I am what I do,” “I am what I have” and “I am what others think.” Scazzero’s four steps are silence and solitude, trusted companions, stepping out of your comfort zone and praying for courage.

What does “going back in order to go forward” mean in Emotionally Healthy Spirituality?

It means facing the family you grew up in, so its patterns stop running your life. In Emotionally Healthy Spirituality, Pete Scazzero notes that the Bible says family sins pass down “to the third and fourth generation.” Scazzero traces the lies from Abraham to Isaac to Jacob, whose name means “deceiver.” Every family hands down unspoken rules, like “Avoid conflict at all costs” or “You must achieve to be loved,” and they don’t vanish when you become a Christian. But in Scazzero’s view, your family does not decide your future. God does. Like Joseph, who blessed the brothers who sold him, you can choose what not to pass on.

What is the Wall in Emotionally Healthy Spirituality?

It is a season, usually set off by a crisis, when your faith seems to stop working. Christians long ago called it “the dark night of the soul.” In Emotionally Healthy Spirituality, Pete Scazzero says God brings you to the Wall through things like divorce, job loss, cancer or a dream that dies, and you can’t grow into maturity without going through it. Scazzero’s own Wall began with a church split, then depression and a marriage crisis. Drawing on John of the Cross, Scazzero says God is freeing you even from your good feelings about him. People who come through judge less, love mystery, wait for God and hold things more loosely.

What is the Daily Office in Emotionally Healthy Spirituality?

It is stopping at set times each day to be with God. In Emotionally Healthy Spirituality, Pete Scazzero admits that morning time with God used to fade within hours. Then Scazzero spent a week with Trappist monks who stopped to pray together seven times a day. Now Scazzero stops for four Offices a day, and Geri Scazzero aims for three. An Office can last from two minutes to 45, and it has four parts: stop what you are doing, center yourself by sitting still and breathing slowly, be silent, and read Scripture, especially the psalms. Keep it simple, Scazzero says. Nothing you do will make God love you any more than he does right now.

What are emotional infants, children, teenagers and adults in Emotionally Healthy Spirituality?

Four levels of emotional maturity. In Emotionally Healthy Spirituality, Pete Scazzero notes that many people are 45 years old but still emotional infants, children or teenagers. Emotional infants expect others to take care of them. Emotional children fall apart when they don’t get their way. Emotional teenagers get defensive and keep score. Emotional adults ask clearly and honestly for what they need, and respect others without trying to change them. Loving well takes skills, Scazzero argues, so Jesus spent three years having 12 disciples practice what he taught. Scazzero’s ministry also offers an online assessment that places you on a scale from infant to adult.

Who is Pete Scazzero?

Pete Scazzero is a pastor and author who started New Life Fellowship Church in Queens, New York, in 1987, added a Spanish-speaking congregation in 1991 and led the church for 26 years, until 2013. Scazzero co-founded Emotionally Healthy Discipleship, a ministry that says its course is used by more than 1,400 churches in North America and that Scazzero’s books and materials are translated into more than 25 languages. Scazzero holds a Doctor of Ministry in marriage and family, hosts the Emotionally Healthy Leader Podcast and, besides Emotionally Healthy Spirituality, wrote the books The Emotionally Healthy Leader and Emotionally Healthy Discipleship.

Is Emotionally Healthy Spirituality biblical?

Emotionally Healthy Spirituality builds each pathway on Scripture, but Pete Scazzero also borrows from monks and contemplative writers. Scazzero draws on Jesus’ sorrow in the garden, Joseph’s tears over his brothers, Job’s grief and Daniel praying at set times in Babylon. Scazzero also cites John of the Cross, Thomas Merton and Richard Rohr, and teaches practices like the Daily Office and the Jesus Prayer. CCEF’s summary of Ed Welch’s review in the Journal of Biblical Counseling says Welch raises several questions about Scazzero’s emphases but overall deems the book a “worthy read.”

Put it into practice

The free tools on the Deepen Your Devotion shelf turn books like this one into steps you can take this week.

Summaries to read next

Comer quotes Scazzero, “We find God’s will for our lives in our limitations,” and Comer’s subtitle speaks of staying “emotionally healthy and spiritually alive.” Comer’s four practices, silence and solitude, Sabbath, simplicity and slowing, add up to a rule of life, a trellis in both books. Read our summary of The Ruthless Elimination of Hurry by John Mark Comer.

Scazzero’s Daily Office stops the day to meet God at set times. The Kendricks start the same way, with a set time and place to pray each day, then add a strategy: praise first, Scripture to pray back to God, and the people to pray for. Read our summary of The Battle Plan for Prayer by Stephen Kendrick.

Untangling Emotions starts where Scazzero’s first pathway does: you bear the image of a God who feels, so your emotions matter. It then teaches four steps to engage them, identify, examine, evaluate and act, and shows how to pour out your heart to God, including through lament. Read our summary of Untangling Emotions by J. Alasdair Groves.

Sources

Facts last checked October 2026.