A perfect scenario with one unfortunate catch. Decide whether you could live with it.
Perfect in every way…
but
Loading…
The Make It or Break It deck holds 100 dealbreakers, shuffled on every visit. Each card reads “Perfect in every way…” and then, under a “but,” one catch, like “they whistle while they chew.” Read it out loud, decide whether you could live with it, and defend your answer. Tap Make it or Break it to deal the next card, and two tally pills count how many you made and how many you broke. Back returns to the last card, and Reset tally clears the count and reshuffles. On a keyboard, M makes it and B breaks it.
Friends, couples and singles who like to argue about something harmless. Make It or Break It takes a minute to learn, needs only one phone, and works for two people or a full table. Most cards are silly, from hobbit feet to a laugh like a car alarm, and the reasons people give show where their real lines are. A few are darker, so it suits teens and adults best.
Jennie Allen offers three simple truths that she says helped her more than anything else: “You will disappoint me. I will disappoint you. God will never disappoint us.” Every Make It or Break It card plays with the first two, since nobody is perfect in every way, and the argument over each flaw shows what a person can forgive. Read our summary of Find Your People by Jennie Allen.
Read a card aloud, then each player says make it or break it and defends the choice. Each card describes someone perfect in every way except one thing, like “they keep the thermostat at 82 degrees year-round.” The fun is in the reasons. Tap Make it or Break it to deal the next card, and the Make It or Break It deck keeps a running count of how many cards you made and broke.
Funny dealbreakers are specific and harmless, so the argument is about taste, not safety. Try “they read every text out loud before replying to it,” “they clap once, loudly, every time they finish a thought” or “they have one joke and they tell it daily.” The Make It or Break It deck puts “Perfect in every way…” in front of each of its 100 catches and asks the table to make it or break it.
The “perfect in every way, but” game shows you someone ideal with one catch and asks if you’d stay. Make It or Break It is a game of this kind: every card reads “Perfect in every way…” and ends with one flaw, numbered from Dealbreaker 01 up. Because everything else is perfect, small quirks start to look forgivable, and that’s when the arguments get good.
A red flag warns that someone could hurt you; a dealbreaker is anything you personally can’t live with. Red flags include dishonesty, cruelty and trying to control you. A dealbreaker can be harmless, like wanting kids when the other person never does. A few Make It or Break It cards are red flags played for laughs, like “they make money on the side through scams.” If a real partner frightens you, the National Domestic Violence Hotline is free, confidential and open 24/7 at 1-800-799-7233.
Pick playful ones about an imaginary person, so nobody feels judged, and listen to the reasons more than the answers. From the Make It or Break It deck, try “they won’t make a plan more than 48 hours out,” “they sleep with every light on and the radio going” or “they take two-hour showers and sing the entire time.” If your partner breaks it over the plans, you’ve learned something real. Save the serious ones, like kids, money or where to live, for a calm talk of their own.
Yes. Make It or Break It on 45 Book Summaries is free and runs in your phone’s browser with no account. It reshuffles its 100 “perfect in every way, but” cards on every visit and tallies how many you made and how many you broke. You need nothing else, and it works for two people or a full table. A few cards are dark, like a partner whose father was a serial killer, so it suits teens and adults.
Facts last checked October 2026.