What the Super-theticals deck does
The Super-theticals deck puts 50 long hypothetical questions on your phone, one scenario per card. Each is a full story with a hard choice inside: a stranger hands you a book about your whole life, you find a suitcase of cash with a warning note, or your clone wants to destroy you. Many start by asking you to name a real person you know. Press Next scenario or the space bar for a new card, or Back to return to the last one. The order changes on every visit. Read each one slowly and take your time.
Who it’s for
Friends who like a long, thoughtful talk: a late dinner, a campfire, a road trip or a slow night in. Super-theticals suits a couple or a small group who don’t mind a question that lingers. Some scenarios are dark or adult, touching on death, crime, sex or betrayal, so the deck is best for adults.
The book behind it
In Find Your People, Jennie Allen notes that most conversations drift toward complaining and gossip because few people know how to ask good questions. A scenario with a real trade-off, often about someone you actually know, gives the table a better question to talk through. Read our summary of Find Your People by Jennie Allen.
16 scenarios from the deck
- Imagine you are given a time machine to travel back in time and give your parents advice on how to raise you. What would you say to them?
- Imagine you are doomed to be haunted by a ghost for the rest of your life. However, you can choose which dead person the ghost is. Who would you choose as your ghost?
- You're walking in a forest and discover a black suitcase. Inside it holds one million dollars and a piece of paper stained in blood with a single word: "Don't". Would you take the suitcase or leave it?
- Imagine you are born to the exact same parents with the exact same genes, only one year earlier or one year later. What parts of your life are the same and what parts of your life are different?
- Who's the most charismatic person you know? If you found a way to bottle up and sell their personality to the highest bidder, how much do you think you could make? How much do you think you could make by selling your own?
- What percentage of people in America (who would be age-compatible) could you be happily married to? What percentage of the same group could be happily married to you? Explain your reasoning.
- Imagine you are driving late at night in a safe but deserted neighborhood, and a dog darts in front of your car. You slam on the brakes, but still hit the animal. Would you stop to help? If you did stop and the dog was dead but had a name tag, would you call the owner?
- Imagine one day discovering that, because of a mix-up at the hospital, your wonderful 2-year-old is not actually yours. Would you want to switch kids to try to correct the mistake? Assume you'd have no further contact with the child you gave up.
- If a technological breakthrough could enable people to travel as quickly and cheaply across the world as they now do between adjacent cities, but at the price of 1,000 deaths a year, would you want the technology developed? Had you lived in 1900 and known that cars would cause 20 million deaths in the next century, would you have wanted to halt their development?
- Name the most bombastic, opinionated, and argumentative person you know who you'd still classify as someone you like. Now imagine at some unknown point within the next six months you will be trapped in an elevator for twelve hours. A service alarm periodically emits a brief high-pitched noise, so sleeping is impossible. Would you rather be trapped with this person or with an unusually large, moderately affectionate, slightly rambunctious dog?
- Name five qualities you screen for in a significant other. Once you've selected your attributes, imagine you get to build your significant other from scratch, just as you would build a character in a video game. You are given a point allotment of 35 points to build your character that is measured on a scale of 1 to 10 for each of the attributes you listed. How do you distribute the 35 character points you are given across these five qualities?
- In a desperate shot at love, you signed up for and have been accepted to be on the TV show Married at First Sight. This season's plot twist is that you have the chance to speed-date 1,000 candidates from behind a curtain, and you only have enough time with each candidate to ask three questions. After hearing the responses from all 1,000 contestants, you must choose which one you want to spend the rest of your life with. What three questions would you want to ask?
- Name someone who is significant to you — not necessarily the most significant person, but someone who has played an important role in your life. Now imagine that this person had never been born. What are three things about your life that would be irrefutably different (people you would never have met, choices you would never have made, experiences you would never have had)? Can you think of anything about your life that might actually improve from their absence?
- Imagine the best possible version of your current self. Think of all the skills you currently possess. You are now able to perform those skills at an extremely high level. You are a verified expert in all the subjects that intellectually interest you. Your various weaknesses and flaws no longer exist. Imagine what your life would be like if you were this person. How different is the life you currently lead from the one you've imagined?
- Name a person who is known by all (or at least most) of the other people playing this game. Now imagine you are a film director with a strange assignment: you need to remake a film that is more than 10 years old starring the named person. You have an unlimited budget and excellent supporting actors, but this person needs to be the protagonist. Your goal is to make this movie as much of a commercial success as possible. Which film do you remake and which character will the named person play?
- Imagine you're hanging out in a library, looking for a new book to read, when a stranger approaches you with a thick untitled book. They put it in your hands and walk away without saying a thing. You open it and flip through the first few pages and realize that the story is oddly familiar. You flip a couple chapters ahead and realize that this is a book about your entire life, and you have just flipped to the chapter that details the encounter you just had with the stranger. You realize that by reading further, you will learn what your future holds. Would you continue reading to see what happens, and if so, how far ahead do you read?
Questions people ask
Is there a free hypothetical questions game?
Yes. The Super-theticals deck on 45 Book Summaries is free, and there is no account to make. Each of its 50 cards stretches a hypothetical into a full scenario, with details, stakes and a trade-off inside, and the order changes every time you open the page. There is no score or timer: a typical card runs about 120 words, and the page’s own advice is “Take your time with these.” Some scenarios touch on death, crime, sex or betrayal, so it suits adults.
What are good hypothetical questions to ask friends?
The best hypothetical questions have no easy right answer and quietly show what someone values. Try “Imagine you are given a time machine to travel back in time and give your parents advice on how to raise you. What would you say to them?” or the Super-theticals card about whether to keep reading a stranger’s book that tells your own future. Ask why after every answer: the reasoning is the interesting part.
What are good moral dilemma questions for adults?
Good moral dilemmas force a real trade-off between two things people care about. One Super-theticals card asks whether you would want fast, cheap travel anywhere in the world if it cost 1,000 lives a year, and whether, back in 1900, you would have wanted to halt the car. Another asks whether you would stop after hitting a dog late at night, and call the owner. There is no correct answer, only honest ones.
How do you play a hypothetical questions game?
Read the scenario aloud slowly, give everyone a minute, then have each person answer and say why. Others can push back or ask follow-up questions. There is no score and no rush: the Super-theticals deck’s footer simply says “Take your time,” and these questions are meant to stay with you all night. When the talk winds down, move to the next scenario.
What are deep hypothetical questions for couples?
Ask about what you want, value and fear in love, then answer honestly and compare. The Super-theticals deck asks which three questions you would ask if you had to pick a spouse from 1,000 candidates behind a curtain, how you would spread 35 points across five qualities to build a partner, and what share of age-compatible people you could be happily married to. Save them for a long date night, when there is time to explain.
Why do people ask hypothetical questions?
People ask hypothetical questions to learn how someone thinks, because a made-up choice shows what they value. Real life lets people dodge a hard choice, but a scenario with fixed rules makes them pick. Because nothing is really at stake, people often answer more openly than they would about their own lives. Twenty of the Super-theticals deck’s 50 cards begin with the word “Name,” and most ask for a real person you know. The follow-up “Why?” is where you learn the most.
Facts last checked October 2026.