Back

Supplements Evaluator

Evaluate common supplements by what works, who may benefit, how much to take, and what to eat instead.

Worth it for most Strong evidence, broad benefit, cheap. The short list almost everyone can justify.
Situational — depends Real uses for some people, in specific contexts. Not a blanket recommendation.
Mostly hype — skip Redundant, unproven, or just expensive sugar. Save your money.
01
Supplements fill gaps

They fill gaps in an already-decent diet.

02
The industry is barely regulated

The FDA does not approve supplements before they're sold.

03
Test, don't guess

Bloodwork (vitamin D, B12, ferritin, omega-3 index) beats blanket dosing.

04
More isn't better

Fat-soluble vitamins (A, D, E, K) and minerals can build up and become toxic in excess.

05
Individualize

Age, vegan or vegetarian diets, pregnancy, and existing medications all change the math.

Sources · NIH Office of Dietary Supplements · Examine.com · ISSN Position Stands · Cochrane Reviews · Mayo Clinic / Cleveland Clinic · ConsumerLab / Labdoor

This is a personal takeaway for general education, not medical advice. Reflects the consensus as of early 2026 — individualize with a doctor or registered dietitian.

A second tool

Protein Gap Calculator

The table above says protein powder only earns its spot when you're short for the day. Find out if you are. List a day of eating and get your gap in grams — plus the cheapest real food to close it.

lb
How much do you exercise or lift?

The target scales with how you train: 0.36 g per pound if you don't (the RDA), up to 0.9 g if you're training hard, dieting, or over 60 — in line with the ISSN's position stand. The grams are estimates from typical portions, so read the gap as a direction, not a decimal. General education, not medical advice.

Questions

What the Supplements Evaluator does

The Supplements Evaluator sorts 19 supplements into three groups: Take it (creatine, protein powder and omega-3), Depends (such as magnesium, vitamin D3, B12, iron and collagen) and Skip (such as BCAAs, mass gainers and greens powders). Search by name or tap a group, then open any row for the dose, the best form, whether food can do the same job, and why. Below the list, the Protein Gap Calculator takes your weight, how much you train and a plain list of a day’s food. AI estimates the protein in each item. You see your total, your target and the gap, and if you are short, three cheap foods to close it.

Who it’s for

Anyone standing in the supplement aisle unsure what is worth the money, from new lifters to people over 60 to vegans checking for gaps. It also answers whether you need protein powder at all. It is general education, not medical advice, so talk to a doctor about bloodwork and drug interactions before you start anything, especially if you are pregnant or take medication.

The books behind it

Mackey argues that you can’t rebuild a whole food in a pill, and that fiber supplements don’t bring the benefits of fiber from plants, which is why the rows worth a look show what food can do instead. He also calls vitamin B12 a must for vegans. Read our summary of The Whole Foods Diet by John Mackey.

Carpenter writes that about 1.6 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight a day seems plenty for people who lift. The Protein Gap Calculator uses that figure, about 0.73 grams per pound, for anyone who lifts three or more days a week. Read our summary of Everything Fat Loss by Ben Carpenter.

Questions people ask

Is there a free protein calculator that counts what you ate?

Yes. The Protein Gap Calculator, part of the Supplements Evaluator on 45 Book Summaries, is free and needs no account. Enter your weight in pounds, pick how much you train, and list a day of eating in plain words, yesterday’s or today’s. AI puts a protein estimate on each item, then the calculator sets your target from your weight and training, shows the gap, and suggests three cheap foods from a fixed list of 12 to close it. The grams are estimates from typical portions, and collagen and bone broth count as zero. If you have kidney disease, ask your doctor about protein first.

Is creatine safe to take every day?

For healthy adults, yes. The International Society of Sports Nutrition’s 2017 position stand found no compelling evidence of harm from creatine monohydrate in healthy people, even at up to 30 grams a day for five years, and no compelling evidence that it hurts the kidneys. The Supplements Evaluator’s dose is 3 to 5 grams a day, every day. You can skip the loading phase: the ISSN notes that 3 grams a day for 28 days raises muscle creatine more gradually. Monohydrate is the most studied form, and no other form has been shown to work better. If you have kidney disease, check with your doctor first.

What is the best form of magnesium to take?

Citrate or an amino-acid chelate such as glycinate, not oxide. In a 2003 trial of 46 healthy adults taking 300 mg a day for 60 days, citrate absorbed best, the chelate beat oxide, and magnesium oxide did no better than a placebo. Keep supplement magnesium at or under 350 mg a day, the NIH upper limit for adults, since more can cause diarrhea. For leg cramps, a 2020 Cochrane review found magnesium unlikely to help older adults in a meaningful way. The Supplements Evaluator’s food swap is pumpkin seeds, almonds, spinach and dark chocolate. If you have kidney disease, ask your doctor before taking it.

Do multivitamins actually work?

Not as a way to live longer. A 2024 study of 390,124 generally healthy US adults, followed for more than 20 years, found daily multivitamin use was not linked to a lower risk of death. If you already eat a varied diet, one adds little. Targeted fixes do more: vitamin D if a blood test shows you are low, B12 if you eat plant-based or are older, and a prenatal vitamin in pregnancy, as your doctor advises. If you take a multivitamin, pick a third-party-tested brand, because the FDA does not approve supplements for safety or effectiveness before they are sold.

Is collagen worth taking?

Probably not for your skin, judging by the most careful trials. A 2025 review of 23 trials with 1,474 people found better skin hydration and elasticity overall, but no effect in trials without drug-company funding and none in the high-quality ones, and its authors found no clinical evidence to support collagen for skin aging. Collagen also doesn’t count toward your daily protein target. If you still want to try it, the Supplements Evaluator lists about 2.5 grams a day for skin and 10 to 15 grams for joints, as hydrolyzed peptides taken with vitamin C.

How much protein do I need a day?

That depends on your weight and how you train: about 0.36 grams per pound if you don’t exercise much, and more if you lift. The RDA is 0.8 grams per kilogram, and the International Society of Sports Nutrition puts most people who exercise at 1.4 to 2.0 grams per kilogram (2017). The Protein Gap Calculator uses 0.73 grams per pound, or 1.6 per kilogram, if you lift three or more days a week, and 0.9 grams per pound for hard training or cutting. A 185-pound person who lifts three days a week would aim for about 135 grams. If you have kidney disease, ask your doctor first.

Sources

Facts last checked October 2026.