Back

Evidence for Christian Belief

Examine Christianity's biggest claims through the evidence for God, the reliability of the Gospels, and the resurrection of Jesus.

Questions

What the Evidence for Christian Belief guide does

The Evidence for Christian Belief guide asks five questions, meant to be read in order: Does God exist? Can we trust the records? Did Jesus rise from the dead? Was this story written centuries early? And last, So what? Each of the first four gives five arguments, one per screen: the claim and the evidence, then a tap on “But what about…” shows the strongest objection and a fair answer. Each question ends with The bottom line. The fifth offers four short readings, ending with a next step. The guide checks off each question you finish and highlights the next one.

Who it’s for

Skeptics and seekers who want to see the evidence before they believe anything, and Christians who believe but have never looked closely at why. It suits a student facing hard questions at college, a parent getting ready for a teen’s questions, and a small group that wants to talk through one question a week.

The book behind it

In Evidence for Jesus, Josh McDowell, who set out as a skeptic to disprove Christianity, gathers the historical evidence in one place: the manuscript record, hostile witnesses like Tacitus and Josephus, Old Testament prophecy and the facts of the resurrection. Three of the guide’s five questions walk that same ground, one argument at a time. Read our summary of Evidence for Jesus by Josh McDowell.

Questions people ask

Is there historical evidence that Jesus rose from the dead?

There is evidence historians weigh, though not proof of the lab kind. Every source says Jesus was crucified; even the agnostic scholar Bart Ehrman, quoted by Josh McDowell, takes it “absolutely for granted.” In 1 Corinthians 15:3–8, Paul lists people the risen Jesus appeared to, from Cephas and more than 500 at once to James and Paul himself, and those two had been skeptics. The Gospels say women found the tomb empty, an odd choice of witnesses in a day when a woman’s word counted for less. The Evidence for Christian Belief guide asks which explanation covers all of these facts at once.

What are the main arguments for the existence of God?

The best known are the cosmological, fine-tuning and moral arguments. The cosmological argument says the universe had a beginning, and what begins needs a cause. The fine-tuning argument points to the numbers of physics, which sit in narrow ranges that allow life. The moral argument says some things are truly wrong, which points to a moral lawgiver; C.S. Lewis opens Mere Christianity with it, noting that even a quarrel over a seat appeals to a Law of Human Nature both people know. The Evidence for Christian Belief guide adds consciousness and the coded information in DNA, and says plainly that none is a knockdown proof.

Is the New Testament historically reliable?

On the tests historians use for other ancient texts, the New Testament does well. More than 5,500 Greek manuscripts of it are known, says the Institute for New Testament Textual Research in Münster, and Josh McDowell notes that no other ancient work has more or earlier copies. Roman and Jewish writers who were not Christians confirm basic facts, like Jesus’s execution under Pontius Pilate. The writers also left in embarrassing details, like Jesus’s own family saying, “He is out of his mind” (Mark 3:21). Good copies don’t prove the claims true, as the Evidence for Christian Belief guide admits, but they show what the authors wrote.

Is there evidence for Jesus outside the Bible?

Yes: Roman and Jewish historians who were not Christians mention Jesus and his execution. The Roman historian Tacitus writes that Christus “had undergone the death penalty in the reign of Tiberius, by sentence of the procurator Pontius Pilatus,” and calls the faith a “pernicious superstition” (Annals 15.44). The Jewish historian Josephus mentions “the brother of Jesus, who was called Christ, whose name was James,” whom the high priest had stoned. They confirm that Jesus lived and died under Pilate, not the miracles. The Evidence for Christian Belief guide covers both in its second question.

What Old Testament prophecies did Jesus fulfill?

Christians point to several written centuries before him, from Isaiah 53 to Micah 5:2. Isaiah 53 describes a servant “pierced for our transgressions.” Psalm 22 speaks of pierced hands and feet and divided garments. Zechariah 11 has thirty pieces of silver thrown to the potter, Zechariah 9 a humble king on a donkey, and Micah 5:2 a ruler from Bethlehem. The Great Isaiah Scroll, one of the Dead Sea Scrolls, was copied in the second half of the 2nd century BC. Jewish readers often see these passages differently: the medieval commentator Rashi reads Isaiah’s servant as Israel, “My servant, Jacob.” The Evidence for Christian Belief guide weighs each one, doubts included.

Where should a skeptic start reading the Bible?

Start with the Gospel of John, read straight through in one sitting, with your questions in hand. John says why he wrote: “these are written so that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God” (John 20:31). Read it critically. Then talk with a thoughtful Christian, and push back on whatever doesn’t convince you. That is the step the Evidence for Christian Belief guide ends with, after its four questions on God, the records, the resurrection and prophecy. The guide is free to read on 45 Book Summaries, with no sign-up.

Sources

Facts last checked October 2026.